D . . . Back to the originally scheduled program . . . when in the downstroke does Hogan get on-plane in your opinion and when after that point does he again get off-plane?
His right arm cant be on the Inclined Plane throughout the entire swing! Look, look,look. On the Plane of the Right Wrist Bend yes, ideally the whole time.
His right arm cant be on the Inclined Plane throughout the entire swing! Look, look,look. On the Plane of the Right Wrist Bend yes, ideally the whole time.
No one is saying that the Right Forearm lays against the Incline Plane at the Top of the Swing. That would be silly.
It's On-Plane when a simple lowering of the Power Package from the Shoulder Sockets returns the Forearm to the Inclined Plane at it's previous location at the end of the Start-up (beginning of Release). The Forearm never went off-plane, but visually, you lost this reference during the shoulder turn and arm lift. The center of the Arc of the Right Forearm is the Right Shoulder and the Right Shoulders movement is limited by the Check reign action of the Left Arm.
Think back to when Yoda demonstrates the Right Arm of Lee Trevino. He has a slight bend in his right elbow and raises the right arm from the shoulder joint until the right hand is way above Lees head. He doesn't bend the Arm anymore. He says that Lee never got into that position, but he tried and thought he did. Anyway, that right forearm was still on-plane. Watch Yoda in his videos demonstrating the straight line delivery Path. His Right Arm goes up and his forearm comes down to the same plane where it was at the end of the startup...;..