[Daryl]

I truly do not know what "pass the hinge" means . Your Hogan pix passed this question.
I SEE what you are saying

HB

The Hinge is Located at the Shoulder. His Hands did not pass his Left Shoulder Hinge Location until after Impact. If his Hands passed his Left Shoulder before Impact then he would have swung "out to the Right" (down the Angle of Approach) farther than you think is correct, after Impact.