[gmbtempe]

"Swinging is Pulling and Hitting is Pushing and thats all."

It is possible to Pull, (Pitch Elbow) and Actively extend the Right Arm. If the Right Elbow leads its pulling isnt it?

Right Arm Swinging. Its not the safest of Right Elbow alignments, tending to muscle tear. You wouldnt pull a car by attaching your right hand to the side of the car and attempting to throw it forward. You wouldnt throw a shot putt. But it can be done for golf. Homer said it was a "beautiful" method, but he also warned of its potential for elbow injury. Not a certainty by any means but there is the potential.

It still sounds like an active move with the right arm which I contend is not swinging. I am probably not literal to the book but thats my take.

You cant do both pulling and pushing in a swing the way I see it. The right arm is just keeping up with the left arm blast off and thus would not be able to thrust. I am sure this thought is nothing new around here.