LynnBlakeGolf Forums

LynnBlakeGolf Forums (http://www.lynnblakegolf.com/forum/index.php)
-   Drills, Training Aids and Equipment (http://www.lynnblakegolf.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Swing Plane Devices (http://www.lynnblakegolf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=3994)

sustainthelag 11-10-2006 01:44 PM

Swing Plane Devices
 
I was considering building a swing plane device similar to what you see in TGM. But before I go to all that effort, would anyone recommend a commercial product they have purchased which they would consider a good value.

lagster 11-10-2006 03:05 PM

Planes
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sustainthelag
I was considering building a swing plane device similar to what you see in TGM. But before I go to all that effort, would anyone recommend a commercial product they have purchased which they would consider a good value.

////////////////////////////////////////////////////////

There is one called EXPLANAR... PRICE... not sure.

Jibe 11-10-2006 06:10 PM

Planes
 
The rim on the Explanar is round wich can give you different planes, so there might be a better solution out there?

powerdraw 11-10-2006 10:34 PM

i built the ultimate planeboard but...not much commercially financially wise MY end...the trick is to have the shaft lay flat on the plane as well, not just pointing to it like the Explanar. ibuilt such a thing out of cardboard that makes 4 pieces of a circle that you can put together, one against the other with all the fittings...then i found out how much it would cost to make a prototype...yikes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

shoved into garbage can with move to new house but had a go on alot of swings on it for my own game, but i kept pics and plans, kinda like a cardboard version of homers, adaptable for all planes and length of sticks and carryable and sendable in a 48" max length in the mail to keep costs down. But just know, that you must keep the shaft as well on that freakin plane.

bray 11-10-2006 11:32 PM

I have found the Explanar to be a great aid in my teaching. It retails for $799.99. The pole rolls on the plane, it is a lot like a dowel rod on a plane board. The only thing I find that the Explanar is missing is the sweet spot plane, however it is great for teaching, learning, and working on your flying wedges....if you know how to use the yellow book and what you are looking for.

It should also be noted that the explanar is adjustuble for different planes...shoulder, hands, etc.

I also know a couple other AI's who use this device with success.

Sorting Through the Instructors Textbook.

B-Ray

bray 11-11-2006 09:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by denny
The Explanar may give a general idea how the plane works on one shiftless plane. Waist high to waist high it is fine.
To date I have not seen anyone do this on a full swing.
Less shift is the goal but humans DO NOT swing on one shiftless plane.
I find that the flash lights drill and the vision track are the best plane training aids.


Denny I agree with you that a shiftless plane is very hard to achieve......I like to use the explanar to teach the flying wedeges. I show my student the wedges on a horizontal surface and then I have them roll them up and down the Explanar. Without the explanar plane shifts do show up, however it is very hard for the student to get excessive right wrist bend on the explanar.

The problem with training aids is that you can find flaws for alot of them......I use training aids for what I need and then set it aside. Having a giant cirle right next to me helps me explain The Golfing Machine conceptualy a lot better.

Sorting Through the Instructors Textbook.

B-Ray

KevCarter 12-01-2008 11:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bray (Post 35862)
Denny I agree with you that a shiftless plane is very hard to achieve......I like to use the explanar to teach the flying wedeges. I show my student the wedges on a horizontal surface and then I have them roll them up and down the Explanar. Without the explanar plane shifts do show up, however it is very hard for the student to get excessive right wrist bend on the explanar.

The problem with training aids is that you can find flaws for alot of them......I use training aids for what I need and then set it aside. Having a giant cirle right next to me helps me explain The Golfing Machine conceptualy a lot better.

Sorting Through the Instructors Textbook.

B-Ray

Apologies in advance for resurrecting an old thread. I am very intrigued by this swing plane device, similar to one Martin Hall used on the Golf Channel.

http://www.pvcsports.com/store/detai...8&productID=57

Anyone have experience with this? Worthwhile for a teacher? Other, better ideas?

Thanks,
Kevin

Sligo33 12-01-2008 03:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KevCarter (Post 58313)
Apologies in advance for resurrecting an old thread. I am very intrigued by this swing plane device, similar to one Martin Hall used on the Golf Channel.

http://www.pvcsports.com/store/detai...8&productID=57

Anyone have experience with this? Worthwhile for a teacher? Other, better ideas?

Thanks,
Kevin

Hi Kevin,

Martin Hall uses the one from pvcsports. He used at the PGA Teaching & Coaching Summit, that i attended in 2006. I use it myself and find it very useful because it allows the club to lie flat on the plane. Other single rail plane devices can let the club travel off plane. Also, it is lightweight and easy to move around, can be stored easily, and is adjustable to accomadate different planes.

You may want to check out mikebender.com. Under training aids Mike has plans for a swing plane board, for $12.95. I have used it at his academy and it is ajustable to allow use of different clubs. I built one using his plans a few years ago for about $125. It weathered (spending 9 months of the year totally exposed to the elements) well for a couple of years, but I finally had to retire it. It is mobile, but being made of would, it is heavy.

Either way it is almost a necessity to have a swing plane board. Personally, I cannot think of a way to give student a clearer image of the swing plane. Hopefully you will find something useful from this post.

KevCarter 12-01-2008 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sligo33 (Post 58323)
Hi Kevin,

Martin Hall uses the one from pvcsports. He used at the PGA Teaching & Coaching Summit, that i attended in 2006. I use it myself and find it very useful because it allows the club to lie flat on the plane. Other single rail plane devices can let the club travel off plane. Also, it is lightweight and easy to move around, can be stored easily, and is adjustable to accomadate different planes.

You may want to check out mikebender.com. Under training aids Mike has plans for a swing plane board, for $12.95. I have used it at his academy and it is ajustable to allow use of different clubs. I built one using his plans a few years ago for about $125. It weathered (spending 9 months of the year totally exposed to the elements) well for a couple of years, but I finally had to retire it. It is mobile, but being made of would, it is heavy.

Either way it is almost a necessity to have a swing plane board. Personally, I cannot think of a way to give student a clearer image of the swing plane. Hopefully you will find something useful from this post.

Sligo33,

Thank you Sir for the detailed answer. I agree, I HAVE to have a plane board. I will check out Mike's website as well. I appreciate the help!

Kevin

joe curtis 12-01-2008 04:16 PM

hank johnson wrote a book that has the directions for bluilding a plane board in it. get a book and lthe directions. what a deal.

KevCarter 12-01-2008 04:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe curtis (Post 58327)
hank johnson wrote a book that has the directions for bluilding a plane board in it. get a book and lthe directions. what a deal.

Thanks Joe.

:golf:

Kevin

mb6606 12-01-2008 04:53 PM

I make a simple board out of two 4' x 8' sheets of styrofoam building insualtion. Layed one on top of the other and cut a circle using a cheap soldering iron. I duct taped the two pieces together and use dowels to prop it up. It can also be used standing on end so you can find the true turned shoulder plane on the backswing. You build another half and duct tape together making a complete plane board.
Pretty simple, cheap and lightweight. Not exactly portable or sturdy for commercial use. You could make it sturdier by gluing with contact cement a piece of plywood to the back.

KevCarter 12-01-2008 05:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mb6606 (Post 58333)
I make a simple board out of two 4' x 8' sheets of styrofoam building insualtion. Layed one on top of the other and cut a circle using a cheap soldering iron. I duct taped the two pieces together and use dowels to prop it up. It can also be used standing on end so you can find the true turned shoulder plane on the backswing. You build another half and duct tape together making a complete plane board.
Pretty simple, cheap and lightweight. Not exactly portable or sturdy for commercial use. You could make it sturdier by gluing with contact cement a piece of plywood to the back.

Thanks Mb6606,

I own a hammer and a screw driver. Not sure when to use which? :) Basically, I'm a mechanical idiot. I'm thinking I am going to go ahead and purchase the one made from pvc pipe. It actually seems very reasonable at $249, and looks very professional. I found Bender's book for making one, but I need to move it constantly, and with my old farts back, I want something very light like the pvc built plane board.

Thanks guys for spending the time helping with ideas. Very much appreciated!

Kevin

YodasLuke 12-01-2008 06:39 PM

soon, I hope
 
I've been working for years on such a device. As soon as I get the patent process started, I'll o.k. it with Lynn and use this site to unveil it to everyone.

It will fit in the trunk of a car, and you'll be able to hit balls with it.

KevCarter 12-01-2008 06:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YodasLuke (Post 58336)
I've been working for years on such a device. As soon as I get the patent process started, I'll o.k. it with Lynn and use this site to unveil it to everyone.

It will fit in the trunk of a car, and you'll be able to hit balls with it.

YodasLuke,

I'll wait and see what you come up with!

Kevin

RickPinewild 12-01-2008 07:52 PM

Plane Board
 
I built one using 1x2 frame and 1/4" plywood. It's just hip high and used for tracing thru impact. I hinged it so it folds flat.

mb6606 12-01-2008 07:57 PM

I always thought you could make one out of the same materials and concept as the pop up tents. Not sure the development costs would be worth the potential revenue.

okie 12-01-2008 08:19 PM

I Benched MY Plane Projects
 
While you are waiting for a suitable plane device using a low bench works nicely! You have to laugh at the simplicity!

Mike O 12-01-2008 11:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by YodasLuke (Post 58336)
I've been working for years on such a device. As soon as I get the patent process started, I'll o.k. it with Lynn and use this site to unveil it to everyone.

It will fit in the trunk of a car, and you'll be able to hit balls with it.

Bucket,
Copy and save this post- my attorney may need it in the future- and if anything happens to me- please use this as evidence. Please make these notes - "I'll O.K." spelled backwards- that's right - Kill. Notice that he doesn't say everyone and Mike O.!! Make sure that you have them make a thorough investigation of Ted's Trunk for DNA material. Look for my body buried under a cement slab - Note: "Balls" spelled backwards - Slabb!!! When I go missing - sneak over to his house and dig up his driveway - if you don't find me there - head around back to his Patio and dig that up- if I'm not there dig up the foundation!!! You need to promise me - in fact any members that have appreciated - just one post that I've ever made - please commit to following this plan out as one act celebrating my life - if something should happen to me - which I think will happen if I understand the secret codes that I'm seeing in this post.

Mike O 12-01-2008 11:36 PM

Help!!!!
 
Hi Everyone,
This is Mrs. Mike O. and well :crybaby: my husband has been missing for 24 hours now and I'm afraid something terrible has happened. Any help that you could provide- I would be deeply indebted to you and if you could find his body - I would give that person my dead husband's entire Homer Kelley Golfing Machine collection.

Sincerely,


Mrs. Mike O.

GPStyles 12-02-2008 08:29 AM

too funny!

Top form Mike O!

YodasLuke 12-02-2008 08:57 AM

I'm feeling a little chipper today
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike O (Post 58354)
Bucket,
Copy and save this post- my attorney may need it in the future- and if anything happens to me- please use this as evidence. Please make these notes - "I'll O.K." spelled backwards- that's right - Kill. Notice that he doesn't say everyone and Mike O.!! Make sure that you have them make a thorough investigation of Ted's Trunk for DNA material. Look for my body buried under a cement slab - Note: "Balls" spelled backwards - Slabb!!! When I go missing - sneak over to his house and dig up his driveway - if you don't find me there - head around back to his Patio and dig that up- if I'm not there dig up the foundation!!! You need to promise me - in fact any members that have appreciated - just one post that I've ever made - please commit to following this plan out as one act celebrating my life - if something should happen to me - which I think will happen if I understand the secret codes that I'm seeing in this post.

What is wood chipper and coffee grinder spelled backwards? (Can't find the body?) &D: &C

Mrs. Mike O,
When do you think we'll get the insurance check, sweetie?
Love, Snookums

KevCarter 12-02-2008 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike O (Post 58355)
Hi Everyone,
This is Mrs. Mike O. and well :crybaby: my husband has been missing for 24 hours now and I'm afraid something terrible has happened. Any help that you could provide- I would be deeply indebted to you and if you could find his body - I would give that person my dead husband's entire Homer Kelley Golfing Machine collection.

Sincerely,


Mrs. Mike O.

Hello Mrs. O,

I'm fairly new at LBG, I didn't get to know your husband very well yet, but I'm pretty sure he would want me to have his boat and riding lawn mower. Please PM me with your email address. I prefer not to post my shipping address here where the authorities may see it.

Kevin

Augusta Golf 12-02-2008 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike O (Post 58355)
Hi Everyone,
This is Mrs. Mike O. and well :crybaby: my husband has been missing for 24 hours now and I'm afraid something terrible has happened. Any help that you could provide- I would be deeply indebted to you and if you could find his body - I would give that person my dead husband's entire Homer Kelley Golfing Machine collection.

Sincerely,

Mrs. Mike O.

Mrs. O,

Your husband has been banned from all of golfdom (forums, courses, driving ranges etc.) and has been relocated to a goat petting zoo/mini-golf facility in Tibet. He will not be returning and has asked you to foward all H.K. documentation to me. Do not trust anyone named Bucket who may state claims to Mike's estate. He is a greasy chicken magnate and cannot be trusted. Mike did ask that you ship his Tommy Lasorda Signature Edition Slimfast's to him at once:

Mike O
Lost Way
Nechung Monastery, Tibet

12 piece bucket 12-02-2008 11:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike O (Post 58355)
Hi Everyone,
This is Mrs. Mike O. and well :crybaby: my husband has been missing for 24 hours now and I'm afraid something terrible has happened. Any help that you could provide- I would be deeply indebted to you and if you could find his body - I would give that person my dead husband's entire Homer Kelley Golfing Machine collection.

Sincerely,


Mrs. Mike O.

Hey Greg!!!! Good to see you out here!!! So it's "Mrs." Mike O now??? Wow Greg that's great . . . . you finally saved up enough cash and had the operation huh? Congrats!!! . . . . perfect timing with the whole Prop 8 deal now you and Mike can really get married. That's so great Greg. Have you decided on your girl name now that you are a chick? How about "Man"dy? Or A"man"da?

Anyway Greg that's so great that you are a girl now . . . .I bet you are pretty too. What did they do about the whole sweater by Darwin deal? Will the estrogin take care of that?

Well congrats again dude . . . I mean girl. I'm soooooo happy for y'all.

Mike O 12-03-2008 01:02 AM

Sick
 
You SICK Ba.....s!!:hang: I'm take'n NAMES!!

cmartingolf 01-07-2009 02:55 AM

plane board
 
I had one made at an upholstery shop out of marine vinyl over heavy foam. I think it was $85. It's held up well. Any decent car upholstery shop could do it.

Picture a right angle triangle (a2+b2=c2).

The a2 part is fixed at 14.5" and the shaft plane c2 is 20". b2 is adjustable for different lie angles.

drewitgolf 01-09-2009 04:35 PM

Whats your angle ?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cmartingolf (Post 59965)
I had one made at an upholstery shop out of marine vinyl over heavy foam. I think it was $85. It's held up well. Any decent car upholstery shop could do it.

Picture a right angle triangle (a2+b2=c2).

The a2 part is fixed at 14.5" and the shaft plane c2 is 20". b2 is adjustable for different lie angles.

Martin,

What length do you use (Plane Line length) and what lie angle you find most beneficial? I use PVC which adapts for all club lie angles, but is to cumbersome to transport.

Thanks

wojo1941 02-26-2009 11:35 PM

Hanks book
 
The book was called "golfs three games" I just sold it on Amazon.

purehitter 02-27-2009 01:31 AM

Dual Track is one of the best!
 
The Duel Track is one of the best out there. You can use it many ways and even hit balls with it. If you are a TGM instructor you can get it at a discount at www.thegolfingmachine.com I think it retails for $129.95. You can get both right hand and left hand models.

John W Rohan-Weaver CMAI, GSEM

gmbtempe 02-01-2011 04:11 PM

Man that sure looks like the Foothills Golf Club south of Phx...

KevCarter 02-01-2011 04:12 PM

Very Cool!

david sandridge 02-01-2011 06:54 PM

why doesn't lynn have one of those. Even the lower half would be good. Use just the two lower sections and I bet the golfgnome would stick two dowels in the upper section to extend the plane. Probably put two orange noodles on that thing too

KevCarter 02-01-2011 07:50 PM

Yoda Doesn't Miss A Thing!
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by david sandridge (Post 82069)
why doesn't lynn have one of those. Even the lower half would be good. Use just the two lower sections and I bet the golfgnome would stick two dowels in the upper section to extend the plane. Probably put two orange noodles on that thing too



:salut: :salut: :salut:

brianmontgomery2000 02-01-2011 08:00 PM

On Martin Hall's Golf Channel video (I think it was that video), he had a small plane board with some props on the back to adjust angle. what was interesting to me was the small pvc pipe segments attached on the back at 45* angle. He then put driveway reflectors in the pvc segments to make a larger "plane" (by virtue of at least the markers).

drewitgolf 02-01-2011 09:31 PM

Plane and Simple
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by whip (Post 82074)
At first I made a plane for basic motion 4ft wide, then I made a half circle plane, then finally a figured out a way to make a full size plane have all the requirements I had wanted for this type of training aid. I wanted it to fit in the back of my car, be able to be made as simply as possible and without specially ordered materials, relatively inexpensive, visually appealing, sturdy and strong while being lightweight, able to hit full shots without damaging the club or the plane and accommodate tall and short players as well as any plane angle with easy adjustability. Homer said that any plane device made should be rectangular.

Whip,

I am sold. Do you have blue-prints on this Plane board?

KevCarter 02-02-2011 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by whip (Post 82085)
You can use masking tape to create straight lines across the face of the plane for forward shaft lean, straight line delivery path or any other geometry you would like to inscribe on the face of the plane. So far the only other plane devices out there are the explanar, the psp inflatable plane, the PVC sports one used by Martin hall, I've also seen the one made of wood by mike bender, but all have their drawbacks. You can only hit balls on the psp inflatable one and that seems somewhat unpractical as well as it is very expensive. You cannot hit full shots on any of the others, the explanar seems overpriced, cumbersome and the black and gray metal is not very appealing. This is the best representation of the plane in my opinion and is the most practical.

Very interested!

miji 02-08-2011 05:41 AM

Explanar
 
I use it daily 5-10 minutes at a time. I won't go to the range without swinging the weighted rollers (long for woods, short for irons). The product only recommends partial swings, but I have no problems working through total motion. Although my laser devices are as useful for working on plane alignments, I like the guided roller for the first move off the ball (my tendency is a fraction outside on takeaway. The heavy weight of the weighted roller forces full release even for those (most unfortunate)of us with the strongest "hold off" tendencies through impact. There is no clubface on the roller, but there is a rod between the handle and roller to place a clip or other "makeshift" clubface in order to monitor hinge actions. It is very interesting to monitor the natural hinge actions which result from imparting mostly right hand vs. mostly left handed forces through the impact interval (no surprises, but very cool to confirm TGM concepts). Although I use the Explanar in front of a large mirror, muscle memory is best attained by not watching the roller make its way around the hoop, but rather focusing on a real golf ball placed on the ground and addressed as if one were intending to actually make contact.

Sligo33 02-11-2011 04:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gmbtempe (Post 82066)
Man that sure looks like the Foothills Golf Club south of Phx...

It certainly does. I worked at the Foothills and spent a lot of time their.

alex_chung 04-04-2011 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by whip (Post 83573)
this thing really looks good on the range and functions even better. Put your student in the plane and move the club for them sliding on the plane or have them swing parallel to it, they will be on their way to better golf immediately when they can see and feel the concept of an inclined plane and how it relates to the golf swing. Completely portable and adjustable, fits any club in the bag and fits entirely in the back of a compact car. Hit full shots parallel to or sliding on the plane without damage to the club or the plane. Experience the feeling of a true on plane shot. your students will be hooked on the swing plane. They will want to warm up on it before there lesson, they will notice it walking to the range, everyone will because you can't miss it. It's more than a training aid, it's a giant billboard for your teaching area. You choose the color of the plane, the embroidery, and the frame. Attachment 2655Attachment 2656Attachment 2657
please pm me for your custom swing plane

I like the look of that. Do you ship outside the US?
Alex


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:01 PM.