mj,
as i haven't seen either book, how do they differ?

-hcw

I don't know what the answer is . . .

However, I have had that video for a long time. The move Hogan put on the driver vs. the move he put on the short irons is distinctly different. With the driver his hands are deeper and the club dips past horizontal. With the short irons his hands don't get shoulder high (Top) and his finish is shoulder high (Top). In the tape he rips a divot with the 4 wood . . . Yoda's 5 downs confirmed.

Heck if I know . . . but I'm pickin 4.

I do know he was doing something different with the short clubs though.

Choo, choo.....
 

It's #1. The other four are all a by-product of, or are made possible through the properties of #1. (6-M-1) Acceleration of a lagging Component willl cease at the instant it achieves an "In-Line" position with its immediately preceding Component." 'Centers and Accumulators can be sequenced, overlapped, omitted, emphasized, triggered and timed as the players understanding and skill permit. But the club's Swing Radius (6-B-0) ends at the "non-lagging" Component nearest to the Clubhead, The "Centers" of the Stroke start with the Feet or the employed Component nearest to the feet in the following order: Knees, Hips, Shoulders, Arms, Right Elbow, Left Wrist-cock and/or Left Hand Rotation." All so beautifully orchestrated to permit the educated hands to aim and direct the clubhead lag pressure via the right forearm and PP#3 toward the Angle of Approach quadrant of the ball or toward the aiming point.

EC

hcw,

I haven't seen "Power Golf", but it appears tp me that it was more of a pure Swing, rather than manipulated. Here's the old iron Swing -

http://www.megspace.com/sports/moeto...side_clip.html

This is a total guess, but probably 2. I think Yoda is hinting that the right foot rises, not pushed off. The closest moving part is the hip, so the motion would be secondary to the hip motion.

Can't wait for the answer.

Re: Choo, choo.....
 

being somewhat in the middle of the aforementioned showdown on the "hip" side i went for #2, but i like this answer (to be honest, i wasn't sure what #1 meant)...maybe it will end up a "trick" question with #1 being what gets done and the rest being the different ways #1 is accomplished...yoda, when do we get the "correct" answer!?#-o

-hcw

The Answer Man Cometh
 

Sunday!

Re: The Answer Man Cometh
 

i'll be logging on early and often! 8-[

Homer On Ben's Right Foot 'Push'
 

Why did Ben Hogan's Right Foot 'push' produce extra Power in his Stroke?

Because...

It enabled him to get his Right Elbow further past the Ball during Release!

The other four answers will indeed increase your ability to deliver Force to the Ball, but only this one was 'Homer's own.'

Congratulations to the 13 percent who got it right!

But, am I wrong or did I read somewhere, perhaps a long time ago, that Hogan was double jointed, just like Garcia? And would that ability to create huge lag because of this also contribute to power?
Jerry