[comdpa]

Interesting, still thinking..

But for the moment I was under the impression that Hinge Action doesn't differntiate the Hitter or Swinger.

Any of the three hinge actions can be executed and the only way that I know you can tell for sure is at follow through to note the club face angle.

Since hinging doesn't occur till impact it seems previous alignments do not define the hinge action for the most part.

I thought I had a handle on hinging, but the fact that you are stating this, makes me wonder and wonder why Kelley had you practice all three without requiring a change to the grip, etc.

Yoda???? Someone clear the fog that is once again setting in

You are right Martee...per 10-19-0, "Hinge Action does NOT differentiate Hitting and Swinging."

Try and incubate this one...7-10, "Use the "Turn" Feel determine the "Roll" Feel."