Divots too deep?

[noproblemos]

When I try the Ben Doyle chip/pitch/punch drills from his video, i keep thinking that my hip rotation drags the wet mop' my hip action snaps it...

But when I do this (while keeping my right elbow in front of the right hip --i'm right handed), then my divots are very deep.

if i keep my elbow to the side of my hip (similar to the Bobby Clampett pics from Annikan on this or Brian's forum), then my divots seem correct (these are with mid irons).

what are other people's experiences with this?

Thanks,